Skip to main content

Table 3 Total volatile fatty acids (VFA) concentrations and individual VFA profiles after 48 h of in vitro ruminal fermentation of purple prairie clover (PPC; Dalea purpurea Vent.) and cool-season native grasses that were harvested when PPC reached the vegetative (VEG), full flower (FL) and seedpod (SP) stages and combined at different ratios

From: Effects of inclusion of purple prairie clover (Dalea purpurea Vent.) with native cool-season grasses on in vitro fermentation and in situ digestibility of mixed forages

Maturity (M)

PPC percentage (PP)

SEMe

P valuesf

0

25

50

75

100

M

PP

M × PP

L

Q

 

Total VFA, mmol/L

      

VEG

32.4c

35.9b

33.5bc

33.7bc

40.0a

1.44

< 0.001

0.001

< 0.001

< 0.001

0.020

FL

28.1

24.4

26.0

26.5

27.5

    

0.306

0.215

SP

26.7a

26.2a

23.9b

23.1bc

21.9c

    

< 0.001

0.723

 

Acetate (A), % of the total VFA

      

VEG

59.4c

60.6c

62.4b

63.0b

65.4a

0.63

0.004

< 0.001

0.001

< 0.001

0.569

FL

58.9e

61.3d

65.2c

67.3b

69.8a

    

< 0.001

0.457

SP

59.2c

60.7c

64.7b

65.1b

67.7a

    

< 0.001

0.601

 

Propionate (P), % of the total VFA

      

VEG

32.0a

29.3b

28.0bc

26.9c

24.2d

0.43

0.122

< 0.001

0.008

< 0.001

0.954

FL

33.5a

30.1b

26.7c

25.2d

23.3e

    

< 0.001

0.001

SP

32.6a

30.5b

27.8c

26.4d

24.3e

    

< 0.001

0.258

 

Butyrate, % of the total VFA

      

VEG

7.6b

8.4ab

8.3ab

8.4ab

8.5a

0.57

< 0.001

< 0.001

< 0.001

0.096

0.261

FL

7.4ab

7.8a

6.9b

5.9c

5.3c

    

< 0.001

0.073

SP

7.8a

7.9a

6.8b

7.3ab

6.5b

    

0.006

0.872

 

Branch-chained VFA, % of the total VFA

      

VEG

1.1c

1.6ab

1.3bc

1.7ab

1.9a

0.14

< 0.001

< 0.001

0.284

0.006

0.907

FL

0.3c

0.9b

1.2b

1.5a

1.6a

    

< 0.001

0.015

SP

0.4c

0.9b

0.9b

1.3a

1.5a

    

< 0.001

0.603

 

A:P ratio

      

VEG

1.87d

2.08c

2.24bc

2.36b

2.72a

0.057

0.102

< 0.001

< 0.001

< 0.001

0.236

FL

1.76e

2.04d

2.44c

2.70b

3.00a

    

< 0.001

0.567

SP

1.82e

1.99d

2.33c

2.47b

2.81a

    

< 0.001

0.397

  1. a,b,c,dMeans with different superscript letters in the same row differ (P < 0.05)
  2. eSEM: standard error of the means
  3. fL linear, Q quadratic, These are linear and quadratic contrasts across PPC percentages within PPC maturity