Hinson et al. (2009) [53]
|
Soybean meal
|
Growing
|
7.66
|
–
|
Comparative slaughter
|
Finishing
|
10.08
|
–
|
Low-oligosaccharide soybean meal
|
Growing
|
9.14
|
–
|
Finishing
|
11.73
|
–
|
Glycerol
|
Growing
|
13.44
|
–
|
Finishing
|
16.98
|
–
|
Kil et al. (2011) [34]
|
Soybean oil
|
Growing
|
20.19
|
–
|
Comparative slaughter
|
Finishing
|
19.33
|
–
|
Choice white grease
|
Growing
|
25.05
|
–
|
Finishing
|
24.99
|
–
|
Kil et al. (2013) [35]
|
Corn
|
Growing
|
9.06
|
–
|
Comparative slaughter
|
Finishing
|
11.08
|
–
|
Stewart et al. (2013) [54]
|
Soybean hulls
|
Growing
|
1.67
|
–
|
Comparative slaughter
|
Finishing
|
4.01
|
–
|
Wheat middlings
|
Growing
|
4.46
|
–
|
Finishing
|
4.72
|
–
|
Heo et al. (2014) [55]
|
Canola meal (Brassica napus)
|
Growing
|
8.80
|
69.8
|
Indirect calorimetry
|
Canola meal (Brassica juncea)
|
9.80
|
72.6
|
Graham et al. (2014) [39]
|
Corn DDGS-high oil (12.1% oil)a
|
Finishing
|
12.99
|
81.7
|
Estimating NE efficiency from a growth study
|
Corn DDGS-high oil (9.6% oil)
|
11.85
|
74.7
|
Corn DDGS-high oil (9.4% oil)
|
11.60
|
71.0
|
Corn DDGS-medium oil (7.6% oil)
|
10.61
|
75.3
|
Corn DDGS-low oil (5.4% oil)
|
9.61
|
66.0
|
Gutierrez et al. (2014) [36]
|
Corn DDGS-BPXb
|
Growing
|
8.78
|
–
|
Comparative slaughter
|
Finishing
|
8.46
|
–
|
Corn DDGS (13.0% oil)
|
Growing
|
9.10
|
–
|
Finishing
|
11.57
|
–
|
High protein DDG
|
Growing
|
9.68
|
–
|
Finishing
|
9.17
|
–
|
Liu et al. (2014 and 2015) [9, 10] (MAFIC work)
|
Corn
|
Growing
|
13.21
|
81.0
|
Indirect calorimetry
|
Soybean meal
|
10.62
|
64.3
|
Wheat bran
|
7.78
|
71.6
|
Wheat
|
11.44
|
74.6
|
Corn DDGS-high oil (10.6% oil)
|
10.21
|
66.5
|
Canola meal
|
8.38
|
72.0
|
Cottonseed meal
|
7.32
|
72.9
|
Li et al. (2017) [11] (MAFIC work)
|
Corn DDGS-high oil (11.2% oil)
|
Growing
|
10.47
|
70.0
|
Indirect calorimetry
|
Corn DDGS-high oil (10.7% oil)
|
10.98
|
77.0
|
Corn DDGS-medium oil (7.6% oil)
|
10.96
|
70.8
|
Corn DDGS-low oil (4.7% oil)
|
9.49
|
67.7
|
Corn DDGS-low oil (3.6% oil)
|
9.28
|
69.0
|
Velayudhan et al. (2015) [42]
|
Dry extruded expelled SBM
|
Growing
|
10.64
|
75.7
|
Indirect calorimetry
|
Li et al. (2018) [14](MAFIC work)
|
Rice bran
|
Growing
|
12.33
|
77.9
|
Indirect calorimetry
|
Corn germ meal
|
8.75
|
72.4
|
Corn gluten feed
|
7.51
|
78.5
|
Peanut meal
|
10.75
|
75.3
|
Sunflower meal
|
6.49
|
67.2
|
Li et al. (2017) [13](MAFIC work)
|
Rapeseed meal-expeller press
|
Growing
|
10.14
|
72.2
|
Indirect calorimetry
|
Rapeseed meal-expeller press
|
11.46
|
80.1
|
Rapeseed meal-solvent extracted
|
7.98
|
65.3
|
Rapeseed meal-solvent extracted
|
9.47
|
75.1
|
Rapeseed meal-solvent extracted
|
7.91
|
72.7
|
Li et al. (2017) [12] (MAFIC work)
|
Corn
|
Growing
|
12.46
|
78.3
|
Indirect calorimetry
|
Soybean meal
|
11.34
|
70.2
|
Rapeseed meal-expeller press
|
11.71
|
74.7
|
Rapeseed meal-solvent extracted
|
8.83
|
76.5
|